AFP Checks vs. State Police Checks: Which Does Your Business Need?

Navigating the world of background checks in Australia can be confusing for employers. With various options available, understanding the distinctions between an Australian Federal Police (AFP) Check and state-based police checks is crucial for compliance and effective risk management. Choosing the wrong type of check can lead to delays, legal issues, and potential risks for your business. This article will demystify the differences between AFP Checks and state police checks, helping you determine which one is best suited for your specific needs, ensuring you're compliant and making informed hiring decisions.

Understanding the Basics: Police Checks in Australia

Both AFP Checks and state police checks aim to uncover an individual's criminal history. They provide employers with details of any disclosable court outcomes or pending charges that may be relevant to a particular role. However, the scope, coverage, and purpose of these checks differ significantly. Let’s explore each type in detail:

Australian Federal Police (AFP) Checks: National Scope

An AFP Check, often referred to as a nationally coordinated police check, is conducted by the Australian Federal Police. This check involves a search of police records across all Australian states and territories. The scope of an AFP Check includes:

National Coverage: It searches the records of all police jurisdictions in Australia.
Comprehensive Overview: It aims to provide a comprehensive overview of an individual's criminal history.
Suitable for National Roles: Generally preferred for positions that have a national or inter-state scope.
Often Mandated: Required for specific industries and roles, particularly those working with vulnerable individuals, sensitive information, or financial assets.

When Should You Use an AFP Check?

An AFP Check is typically the correct choice when:

Working with Vulnerable Groups: Roles in healthcare, education, childcare, aged care, or disability services often require a nationally coordinated check.
National or Inter-State Operations: If your business operates across multiple states or territories, an AFP Check provides a consistent screening approach.
Roles with Sensitive Information: Positions that have access to personal data, confidential company information, or financial assets.
Government and Public Sector: Many roles in these sectors require a national security clearance, often involving an AFP Check.
Visa and Immigration: Certain visa applications require an AFP Check as part of the application process.
Specific Legislation: Some federal legislation requires an AFP Check rather than a state-based check.

State Police Checks: Regional Focus

State police checks, on the other hand, are conducted by individual state and territory police agencies. These checks are more localized and typically search records within that specific jurisdiction. Key features of a state police check include:

Limited Scope: The search is limited to the police records of the state or territory where the check is conducted.
Regional Focus: Suitable for roles and businesses that operate within a specific state or territory.
May Vary: Requirements and processes can vary between different state and territory agencies.
May not be accepted nationally: a state police check is generally not accepted in other states and territories for compliance or legislative requirements.

When Should You Use a State Police Check?

A state police check might be suitable in situations such as:

Localised Operations: If your business operates solely within a particular state or territory and hires candidates solely from within that jurisdiction.
Non-Sensitive Roles: Where a role is not considered to be high-risk, and a general check is sufficient.
Internal Policies: Some internal company policies may accept a state police check, however this would need to be carefully reviewed.
General Employment: Some general roles may be suitable for a state check, provided this is allowed as per legislation and not required to be a nationally coordinated check.

Key Differences Summarized

To help you easily distinguish between the two, here’s a summary table:

Feature	AFP Check (Nationally Coordinated)	State Police Checkast
Coverage	National, across all states and territories	Limited to a specific state or territory
Scope	Comprehensive overview of national criminal history	Regional criminal history only
Ideal for	National roles, high-risk sectors, vulnerable groups	Local roles, within a single state or territory
Compliance	Often mandated by federal law for certain roles	May be sufficient for specific state or territory requirements
Inter-state recognition	Generally accepted in all states and territories	Generally not accepted outside the issuing state or territory

The Impact of Choosing the Wrong Check

Choosing the incorrect police check type can have significant implications:

Compliance Issues: You may fail to meet legal requirements, which could lead to penalties or fines.
Increased Risk: Hiring someone with a criminal history not revealed by a state check could increase risks for your business and clients.
Inefficiency: You might need to conduct a second check if the first one does not meet the requirements, resulting in delays and added costs.

How to Choose the Right Check for Your Business

To ensure you're making the right decision:

Assess Risk: Consider the level of risk associated with the roles you are filling. Higher-risk positions and those working with vulnerable people generally require an AFP Check.
Understand Legal Requirements: Review relevant federal and state legislation and industry-specific guidelines.
Geographical Scope: Consider where your business operates and the location of your candidates.
Consult Experts: Seek advice from HR professionals, legal advisors, or accredited background check providers like Avvanz.

How Avvanz Can Help

Navigating the complexities of police checks can be challenging. Avvanz offers streamlined background check solutions that make the process easier, ensuring you choose the right type of check and remain compliant. Our services include:

Expert Guidance: Our team can provide expert advice to help you choose the appropriate check for your business.
Efficient Processing: Our user-friendly platform streamlines the application and reporting process.
Compliance Assurance: We stay up-to-date with the latest regulations to ensure your checks meet all requirements.
Comprehensive Solutions: We offer both AFP Checks and state police checks, depending on your specific needs.

Conclusion

Understanding the differences between AFP Checks and state police checks is crucial for businesses hiring in Australia. By carefully considering the scope, coverage, and purpose of each check, you can ensure your background screening processes are effective, compliant, and contribute to a safer workplace.

Share this story: